When Bob and Char Nelson relocated from Provo to the Harvard-Yale area in Salt Lake City, they knew it was only a matter of time before they would remodel their new, old house. Right after they moved in, they finished the basement, but the main floor, upstairs and exterior needed some work, too.

Energy efficiency before

Before: (Annie Schwemmer)

Their original home was built in 1927, but had undergone a major renovation and addition in the 1970s. The back of the house had some odd shapes, and the exterior had ben finished with fiberboard paneling that was starting to fall off. The Nelsons sometimes felt like they were living in a stranger’s home. Char loved the house and Bob was getting used to it, but it wasn’t quite “theirs’” just yet.

Throughout the house, space was used unwisely, leaving hardly any storage space. In this stage of the remodel, it was time to look into the exterior of the house and reconfiguring the interior. Their two oversized bathrooms wasted valuable space. “The master bathroom was 10×13 with a whirlpool tub that we never used,” Bob says. “It had a walk-in shower with a “porthole” window. It also had a strange ramp leading up to the tub. Overall, the bathroom had a lot of wasted space.”

As the demolition proceeded, it became clear that the ramp in the bathroom was covering all kinds of problems in the structure and plumbing. Structural members had been randomly notched to accommodate the spaghetti bowl of pipes and tubes running under the floor. “Our contractor took a picture of it and the project management team thought it was a set-up because it was so oddly put together.”


Energy efficiency after

After: Renovation Design Group designed a new exterior back side of the house to fix an oddly shaped bedroom that was impacting the exterior appeal. It also shows the new stucco, solar hot water panel on the roof, and new triple pane windows. (Annie Schwemmer)

The bathroom remodel freed up some square footage that was reconfigured to expand an adjacent bedroom and add some badly needed storage in the form of two closets. The Nelsons stayed within the footprint of the original house, but came away with much more usable space and beautiful finishes, such as hardwood floors throughout. The fun fixtures and finishes they selected made the home their own. However, beauty and functionality were just two goals of the remodel. The Nelsons obviously wanted their house to be structurally sound but they were also interested in achieving the best level of energy efficiency possible.

Adding solar energy

Bob had long been interested in generating his own electricity with solar panels. Because this house’s backyard faces south, it is the ideal orientation for photovoltaic solar panels. When customers generate their own power, it is used in the home.

If there is excess power generated, it will be used by someone else, but your meter will keep track of this excess amount. Since the excess is most often generated in the summer, this credit will be applied to the home’s winter power bill, but there is a time limit on this process. At the end of this period, the account is set back to zero, and the owner loses credit for any excess power at this point. (In California, the power company will buy this power, but that is not the current process here in Utah.)

Therefore, the Nelsons decided to just install enough panels to generate as much energy as they calculated they would use in the accounting period. They ended up installing 15 panels, as well as a solar water heating system. They installed the system in September and through the winter they didn’t generate much energy. But in March and April, they are already generating more than they did last September. Last month, they paid $17 for electricity and natural gas combined.

Those savings are offsetting the initial cost of the system. Bob figures that it will take 12 years for the solar panels to pay for themselves in energy savings and five to six years for the solar hot water heater to pay for itself. The Nelsons are definitely moving in the right direction, and they haven’t even had a sunny, summer yet.

In addition to the solar panels and solar water heating system, the Nelsons also replaced the windows and all of the attic and exterior wall insulation that was accessible. We recommend adding insulation wherever you can when you are remodeling an older home. With the temperature swing between our Utah seasons, proper insulation is a must-have. Remodeling is a perfect time to look into adding or upgrading your insulation and updating to energy efficient windows. The Nelsons actually chose to install triple-pane windows and open-cell foam insulation, and maintain larger roof overhangs on the south and west sides of the home to minimize heat gain and therefore the amount of energy required to cool the home. That alone helps with your energy bill, even if you are not generating your own electricity.

The Nelsons’ project had more interesting aspects that we will have to save for next week. They had a few amazing discoveries in the construction process. We will just say they feel safer now that they remodeled. Watch for details in next week’s column when we revisit the Nelsons in Harvard-Yale.

Ann Robinson and Annie V. Schwemmer are the Principal Architects and co-founders of a residential architectural firm focused on life-changing remodeling designs at RenovationDesignGroup.com. Send comments or questions to as*@Re*******************.com

Remodeling for energy efficiency